If you’re buying a new computer and it comes with a mouse, you’re probably looking at a shitty machine bundled with a relic. The age of the mouse is over. Anyone pushing them with new computers is selling crap.
I’m so tired of mice. I’ve gotten used to touchscreens, and trackpads, and now whenever I have to use a simple pointer, I feel like I’ve travelled back in time. I almost expect all my icons to go 8-bit. And for years now, they’ve just been awful. When was the last time you really loved a mouse? When was the last time you were like, “damn, this is a great mouse and I enjoy using it?” Odds are, if you have had that experience in the last five years, it’s been with a mouse that does a lot more than simple mousing. It probably had a touchpad on its top, or a gyroscope inside of it, or other way to manipulate data in a non-linear, two-dimensional fashion. In other words, it was probably much more than a mouse.
We’re getting trained by our phones and our tablets do do more and more with our hands. Some of those mobile gestures are making their way to the desktop—think of the way you can pinch to zoom on a trackpad now. And as we become more and more accustomed gestures, mice, and the single-point, two-dimensional actions they demand, make less and less sense. They feel constraining. Limiting. And that’s because they’re outdated.
If the mouse were an automobile, it would qualify for collecter car plates. Douglas Englebart created a mouse prototype in 1963, and then showed it off to the world in 1968 at the now-famous Mother of all Demos. The Macintosh took it mainstream in 1984, and for nearly 30 years now it’s been giving us all a way to move a curser around the screen and select. And little more.
Today at any given time we may be running 20 apps at once, with a dozen or more browser windows open, while trying to sort through more data in a few seconds than an early Cray supercomputer saw over the course of its lifetime. And yet we still use tools designed for a simpler time, with simpler needs.
And the thing is, the thing we’ve all been waiting for, the thing that’s going to make us work faster, and more efficiently and be less prone to repetitive stress injuries and wrist strain and just plain old frustration—that thing is already here. It’s gesture-based computing, and your operating system already supports it.
Gesture-based computing gives us far more precision and control over the interface. We can manipulate not just points but entire screens. We can perform complex actions that once required keyboard shortcuts, with just our fingertips. Combining one movement with another lets us do things that the mouse’s limited range of motion could not—at least not without throwing a staggering numbers of buttons into the mix.
Apple, as usual, is ahead of the curve on this. The touchpads in its laptops, combined with the gestures built into Mountain Lion let us perform all sorts of tasks with a few simple swipes. The Magic Trackpad is taking this action to the desktop. And the lone mouse that it does sell, the Magic Mouse, is essentially a multi-touch device that also does mouse things.
It’s not something lost on other hardware makers. All the smart ones are already moving past the mouse. When Vizio showed off its new line of stunning all-in-ones at CES this year,for example, there was a gorgeous keyboard and trackpad, and even a remote, but nary a mouse in sight.
But if Apple is ahead of the curve, Microsoft is already around the bend. While Windows 7 supports some gestures, Windows 8 takes it to an entirely other level. It’s going to make touchscreen computing a reality. But you don’t even have to wait for that to ship to see Microsoft’s real mouse-killer: Kinect.
The Kinect is the most revolutionary input device on the (mainstream) market. It’s transformative, as a legion of hackers show day after unexpected day. It’s the first mainstream device that’s lets us manipulate data in three dimensions with just our bodies. It is the gateway drug to an era where the input device is simply something in the background, an unobserved and unblinking eye that captures everything without being noticed itself.
It’s no coincidence that the Kinect came out of gaming. If you want to see the future of how we’ll work, it’s already out there in the present of how we play. The gaming industry’s devices for play have the capability to completely alter the way we work. Gamers often have the need to perform many complex actions simultaneously. And the industry has responded to that with all manner of input devices, many of which are single function, while others may use your entire body. It’s made for an industry that’s not only open to experimenting with interaction, but that recognises this experimentation can be a selling point in itself. It’s why the PC with the most innovative multitouch trackpad on the market today came out of the gaming industry.
There is one place mice still rule: first person shooters. Thanks to their precision and speed, mice are still beloved tools for FPS aficionados, and a handful of other tasks as well. Yet that doesn’t make them right for everyone, or even most people, in most situations.
I mean, if I want to rope a steer, I’m still going to want to be on horse. But that doesn’t mean I want to commute to work on one. Giddyup.













Put The History of Time In Context With a Click of Your Mouse
Guam's Solving Its Snake Problem With a Horrifying Rain of Poisoned Mouse Paratroopers
Gigabyte's Aivia Uranium Gaming Mouse Comes With Its Own Tiny Monitor
I know this is a big ask, but can we either get rid of that clear button or have a box asking if I really want to do it? Please? Is it that hard to clear the box that you need a button specifically for it?!
Right, third go; I’d love to see the Kinect enabled office!
Personally I’ve never liked trackpads; uncomfortable to use. But then I pretty much always resort to keyboard shortcuts when I want to do something quicker.
“When was the last time you really loved a mouse? When was the last time you were like, “damn, this is a great mouse and I enjoy using it?”
Hmm….Today?
Call me old fashioned, but god I love just a simple mouse with a few buttons and a scroll wheel that fits perfectly in my hand, No fancy touch pads or gyroscopes on or in my mouse, Thank you.
Never liked touch pads, never will like touch pads, I would much rather be forced to use only a graphics tablet as my main interaction with a computer, and even when I do use my graphics tablet, I use a mouse alongside it.
Maybe I just like my hand not cramping up with a mouse like it does when I’m forced to use a touch pad.
“Gesture-based computing gives us far more precision and control over the interface. We can manipulate not just points but entire screens. We can perform complex actions that once required keyboard shortcuts, with just our fingertips. Combining one movement with another lets us do things that the mouse’s limited range of motion could not—at least not without throwing a staggering numbers of buttons into the mix.”
I agree with most of this above paragraph, but not the word precision.
The one thing that i DESPISE about touch screens is the severe lack of precision. When browsing the web, something simple like highlighting text ends up taking about 20 times the length of time, and hitting links is also far more imprecise.
The day the mouse dies will be a sad day indeed. I loathe trackpads, they’re imprecise and unresponsive, not to mention a pain to use, especially when trying to select text or move a window.
The first thing I do with a new laptop is disable the trackpad and get a mouse.
As for using something like Kinect… Potentially good if you’re standing away from the computer and want to do something, but when you’re sitting down? Mouse and keyboard wins.
Apparently you haven’t used a MacBook Pro / Air trackpad then. They are extremely sensitive, responsive and accurate. Also, being made of matte glass, they don’t get sticky like a glossy touchscreen. I tend to use both a mouse and the trackpad when using my MacBook. Mouse for most things as it is a bit faster for clicking than tap to click, trackpad for gestures. When I don’t have a mouse though, the trackpad is fine.
I agree completely about using Kinect though. It would be horrible to have to wave your arms in midair to do something.
One of the other things that springs to mind is that for a “normal” office environment, a touch based system (Screen, not track pad) would mean a radical re-design of the office space and desk area.
“When was the last time you really loved a mouse?”
Right now, and there’s nothing fancy about it. It has a left click button, a right click button, and a wheel. I guess it being wireless is kinda fancy…
There’s no way I’d use a computer without a mouse, I’m thinking of buying a tablet but I’d make sure I also get a mouse to use with it.
A few days ago, the rechargeable battery in my mouse gave out. For now, I’m using my Bamboo Pen & Touch which is capable of the gestures you mentioned.
It sucks.
Not the product, that’s great, and has its uses. But for general, day to day browsing? Nope. It’s a lot more uncomfortable (for me) to move my finger against a perpendicular surface than it is to continuously have my hand gripped on a purposefully shaped object which only needs a tiny nudge to get to the right place.
Of course operating systems should now be incorporating different methods of input, but for use in conjunction with a mouse, rather than to replace them. To welcome the death of such a crucial object shows a hideous understanding of modern computing; it isn’t ALL turning into touchscreen gestures, and modernisation is not simplification to the extreme.
Gestures are perfect for mobile devices, but the mouse or something like it will hopefully live on forever.
I agree, I tend to use both a mouse and the trackpad on my MacBook. Each has it’s advantage. Mouse is faster for clicking & moving (and more comfortable), trackpad allows for quick manipulation of windows etc. with gestures.
Using anything other than a mouse on a desktop would be awkward to use. Trackpads are less precise, touch inputs on a giant desktop screen, reaching over the desk to touch the screen would be really uncomfortable. A kinect-like thing would be useless if you have limited space.
A touch screen on a laptop might just be usable.
It is incredibly naive to say that any PC you buy which includes a mouse is “shitty”
Maybe you should have titled this: “It’s time to kill your trackpad” with a picture of a trackpad cut in half over a trackpad trap and have a massive rant about how much you hated trackpads? I thought Gizmodo is supposed to be a neutral biased technology blog? Not a sounding board for the authors personal opinion. Maybe you could get some employment as an Apple “Genius”?
I’ve always loved my mouse. I love my current mouse (G9x), and I loved my previous mouse (MX Revolution (which I consider better than my current one)). Trackpads are the bane of computing, especially the new glass ones that Apple have been installing left right and centre. I went to use one of those in an Apple store, and it was so disgustingly horrible I almost cried. Trackpads on laptops are similarly as bad, especially the ones with incorporated scrolling areas, as if moving your finger in a 1″x1″ box isn’t hard enough, to have half of that dedicated to scrolling.
In short, I guess that you never use a mouse, and never plan to use a mouse in the future. I’d like to see how that works out for you. I’d like to suggest another Gizmodo topic though: Maybe we should drop the C programming language because it’s old and “out of date”. We should all use something like Java or Linden Scripting Language instead, because they’re “new” and so much cooler than rusty old C.
Kind of funny how older generation mice are somehow “better” than the latest generation, weight-customizable, many-button-mashable mice of today.
I still have my MX510 and I currently use an MX518 and I find them the best of any mice I’ve used, the lower DPI and less numerous buttons notwithstanding.
I’ll take my £30 Logitech over any fancy £150 Razer any day.
I strongly disagree with a lot of this to be honest. First of all making the point of getting rid of it because it is old is silly, I’m all for innovation but if it’s not broke..?
The reason mice haven’t changed that much is because they do their job better than anything else. Precision, comfort to hold, ease of use (clicking and dragging on a track pad is like thumb wrestling with yourself).
A major point I feel most people forget is you try working a full day in front of your computer stroking your screen and then tell me you’re not fed up floating your arm over your desk.
Call me old fashioned but I find a mouse far more useful than a trackpad. Sure if I’m skimming some websites I use the trackpad for going back and forth, but otherwise a mouse is far better, especially for prolonged use.
I agree. There is no tech that can substitute the mouse yet.
In my line of work, CGI/3d Design, at the stages of production i work at (after modelling), nothing beats a mouse. In fact, in almost every single thing i do on a computer, id rather use a mouse. I find it very very precise (more so than gestures or touch screens), far more ergonomic (large scale touch screens leave my arms tired, pen+tables take up too much room on my desk) and basically the best input device currently available. People are so quick to try and re-invent the wheel, without stopping to consider that maybe the wheel is a great design, and only something completely different (not touch/gestures, maybe mind control) will actually improve things. Voice commands that actually work would be a great addition, but ive tried so many bits of voice command software, none of it speeds up working at all, and its v impracticable in some circumstances. I remember reading about foot based controls a few years ago, ive always thought that that would be a great idea.
But no, a touch screen is great on a mobile device, but for large screens, design work or pretty much any other kind of work, a mouse wins. With a touch screen you have to move your body around a much larger surface, you precision is hindered by your finger covering up the selection area, leaning on the surface covers up the screen, reaching up to the surface is fatiguing.
Gestures? even worse! having to wave my arms around is not going to work for any length of time in a professional environment.
The real question is, what is wrong with the mouse as an input device, how can it be improved?
I bought an apple magic mouse, its great for gestures like back, forward etc, but without tactile feedback, precise scrolling and scroll click (both essential in the software i use) are impossible! So i have to plug in a standard PC mouse instead.
I thought I was going to come on here and be the only person sticking up for the humble mouse. I’m glad I’m not! I do tend to use a lot of keyboard shortcuts for some things, but general navigation nothing comes close to a mouse. Don’t get me started on how awful trackpads are to use for any length of time. I genuinely can’t believe the author is suggesting that they’re more user-friendly than a mouse!
As has been said, there’s nothing wrong with the mouse. Leave it be!
I gotta say, I didn’t think the support for the mouse would be as big either. But I guess that is a combo of the fact the mouse is a solid piece of tech regardless of what the writer might try to say, and that us Gizmodians (Totally the official name for us) don’t like been told what tech is outdated and useless until we decide it is.
“If the mouse were an automobile, it would qualify for collector car plates.” No, it would be a Ford Focus while the original mouse was a Ford Popular – the technology has moved on but the underlying reason for its existence still remains – a reliable method of controlling an interface, touch and gesture have uses – I like swiping web pages on my tablet – but for true precision the mouse has a lot of life left in it, trying to manipulate text boxes, lines etc in a design using an upright screen or by gesture would be difficult at best and literally painful over the course of a day. All these technologies; mouse, tablet+stylus, touch, gesture have a place, all are tools that can and need to be used for different tasks.
/rant
I think the comments are pretty clear on this one — it’s not time to exterminate the mouse.
If something out there is better than the mouse then we’ll move to that medium in time, for now it sounds like you’re forcing the reinvention of the wheel.
Personally, any touchscreen method of controlling a mouse is inferior to actually using a mouse. The complete lack of precision is terrible. The frustration I feel when I lift my finger off of a trackpad and see the cursor move is indescribable, particularly when I’m working on something precise.
With the greatest of respect, I think this article is either ahead of its time or a misguided attempt to look clever. I’ll go with the former because it’s likely that mice will one day be old tech. Until then, however, I think the majority of people would disagree with the article.
That said, respect to Mat for putting his opinion out there. It takes a brave man to make such a declaration.
Fingers on a touchscreen will never give the precision needed for many tasks, so mice, or at least touch surface mice will be around for a long time.
As for trackpads, I’ve never liked them. They are just the mobile solution to a mouse so are second choice in my book. They have improved a lot, Macbook trackpads are decent, but stuck in front of the keyboard they will always feel like an awkward compromise for a full desktop system, which means a separate mouse that is shaped to your hand. To the contrary of what you said, mice are better ergonomically than trackpads.
As for Kinect and things like that, how can they ever be used with accuracy anywhere near a mouse so as to be better in ‘normal’ use of a computer?
As a graphic designer, I can’t imagine the hell that would be trying to use photoshop without something as accurate as a mouse. I’m not saying I wouldn’t ditch the mouse but only for something more precise.
Simple test – try photo restoration using a track pad. I also use a Wacom tablet but only in tandem with a mouse (+1 Tacos!).
I’m assuming this article is just provocation. Please don’t tell me it’s serious, thought out journalism. Some of us use computers to actually do more than scroll through websites.
I have promised not to give a star. But I want you to have one so here is one more like hoping you get there soon.
Glad some other people also use a mouse with their tablet, I know some people find it weird and rather just omit the mouse out of the equation. Personally, been left handed, the tablet is ideal for the left hand combined with the mouse in my right hand.
My greasy fingers would like to disagree with you. Its fine with track pads, but I hate using touch screens… Maybe I should stop stroking my oily locks and then immediately touch things.
Swap my mouse for a lousy touchscreen? No way. This new “touch” fad (and that’s what it is) is only for lazy people who can’t be arsed to simply use a normal interface. You think I’m gonna play BF3 on a touchscreen? lmfao I don’t think so. And as for smartphones, Well, You crack that screen and what? No phone AT ALL. At least with a keypad you can still use it until repair. Future? I think not. Retarded is the word I would use.
I love my mouse! mine has two scroll wheels (second one is thumb operated and programmed to scroll between tabs) and a precision point button which slows the cursor movement down.. its wonderful!
In the interests of experimentation though, I just screwed a 2.3m projector screen to my bedroom wall and I plan on using Johnny Lee’s Wiimote project (http://johnnylee.net/projects/wii/) to turn an IR laser into a “mouse” I can use from my couch or bed. Will let you know how it goes
Ah, the internet is a wonderful thing. It’s gratifying to see so many sound-minded people replying.
Trackpads are a hellish invention and those red/blue nipples are just as terrible.
Gestures have their place, but like wobbly windows and transparency, I suspect we’ll go all over the top at first, then reign back to a more pragmatic functional level.
Yes, tech websites are mindlessly raving about the modal desktop like it’s something new, but even Windows 8 and OS X Mountain Lion are still more or less WIMP.
Mice are still the fastest, most accurate, most comfortable way to control a desktop-paradigm interface.
That said, I avoid removing my hands from the keyboard at all costs. If you think gesture-based modal desktops are new and efficient, you should compare them to a tiling window manager with good keyboard shortcuts. Although that has a far steeper learning curve admittedly.
Trackpads are inherently less functional than mice. Mice have fine grained sensitivity on two axes, plus (typically) three buttons that give haptic click-response and can be held or not without affecting the fine-grained movement.
It’s that combination that is the key advantage, and trackpads, touchscreens, joypads and kinect-style motion sensors all fail to improve upon (wiimote and PSmove style ones are effectively 3d mice, but they are adversely affected by the accuracy of their position sensors).
They’ll take my Microsoft Wheel Mouse Optical when they pry it from my cold, dead hands!
the day the mouse dies is the day that someone develops a superior method of fast, pinpoint accurate, reliable and ergonomic data control and manipulation. None of the methods you have talked about can achieve that.
I usually disagree with Mat’s articles but this is one really takes the biscuit. :T
Like many other people; right now. I really do love my mouse and really hope it doesn’t die any time soon. Microsoft Intellimouse Explorer 3.0. The greatest!
Some points:
• Can you hold out your arms touching your screen for more than 5mins comfortably? – Rules out touch screens.
• Have you ever tired to play a game with a touch pad?
• Tried Graphic design with a touch pad?
• Select and drag on a touch pad can be painfully awkward.
– Rules out touch pads. (Yes they are great for laptops and portability)
Mice are the most efficient, comfortable and accurate way to interact with a computer, and current technology is no competition to replacing the mouse.
Alright, you continue using your computer for basic web browsing, silly apps, and typing documents. While the few of us that actually use our computers and workstations for something that requires a little more precision, for example, complex software, with complex interfaces, which require a lot of screen travel, and a touch not attainable by sausage finger interaction, we would like to keep our mice thanks. I don’t look forward to the day when I have to spend 8 hours of every days, whizzing my hand and arm around a screen, trying furiously to mash buttons, menus, and write complex scripts in Maya.
You’ll not take my mouse off of me either for work of for home… I work in a 2d/3d design office there is no way we’d get rid of the mice, it simply wouldn’t work. At home I simply couldn’t play games on my PC/Mac without a mouse, it’s just not going to happen.
Mice FTW !!!!
Does anyone have an editorial capacity at Giz?
I know the irony of what I’m about to type. This is purely an article to get people posting about its clear attempt to troll mouse users.
The mouse will never die. Everything else is terrible unless its used in tandem with a mouse. Simples.
Seriously WFT, mice still rule. Sure, capacitive touch screens on phones and tablets generally have excellent interfaces designed for fingers – but there’s still plenty of times when I’ve wished for more control. The mac trackpad is certainly better than PC equivalents, but as soon as my macbook gets on a desk for some serious work, out comes the mouse. When comes to desktops, touch screen variants are a gimmick unless you just want something for the kitchen. Otherwise, nothing but nothing beats the mouse for speed, comfort and precision. I just love my Anywhere mx with it’s hyper-fast scrolling.
>> When was the last time you really loved a mouse?
Love by Cyborg R.A.T 9 every time I grasp it.
>> And yet we still use tools designed for a simpler time, with simpler needs
Wheels are from a simpler time, yet we still use them. Should we stop using wheels?
>> Microsoft’s real mouse-killer: Kinect
When did this become satire ^_^. Thank you for the thought it gave me one hell of a chuckle.
>> captures everything
Except subtle movements or anyone sitting down. You know two things people do when using a computer.
>>It’s why the PC with the most innovative multitouch trackpad on the market today came out of the gaming industry.
Agreed with the razer blade, I would however use a mouse with it.
But then again I don’t really care about people forcing their opinions on me.