Not a single smartphone in out right now will be able to upgrade to Windows Phone 8. If you’re a recent customer, you might be frustrated. Rightfully so. But if you care about the dazzling future of Windows Phone, get over it.
What Microsoft is doing with Windows Phone 8 is what it has to do: laying cement for an OS that will last deep into the future — or at least as long as you’ll own your phone. Your Lumia is based on Windows CE, software that was first released back in the early 90s. It’s ancient, and it’s holding the entire platform back. WP8, and its incompatibility with the phone you might own right now, is a much-needed fresh start.
More than that, it’s a fundamental shift, uprooting everything; Microsoft’s packing up the house, putting it on the back of a truck, and moving it out of the dead-end suburban cul-de-sac and onto a gorgeous country estate. WP8 will now share common code with the impending desktop and tablet versions of Windows 8. If this sounds complicated, it shouldn’t: by next year, every new Windows computer, slate, and phone will have the same modern software DNA, which will give Microsoft-friendly handsets access to the best programming magic available.
This software sea change is coupled with a hardware triumph: multi-core processors (up to a staggering potential 64), 720p hi-res screens to show off WP’s design crown, NFC for the wireless economy of the future, and other future-resistant treats. And it has to, because Microsoft screwed this up pretty grandly out of the gates: WP devices have always been underpowered compared to their iOS and Android peers, because of Microsoft’s iron grip. Strictly dictated specs kept the platform out of the horrible hell swamp of Android fragmentation, but they stymied the hardware; even the shining prince Lumia 900 is out of date on the inside. You getting “screwed” is how that gets fixed.
And there’s simply no way to do it without drawing a line in the silicon. From this point forward, things will be great. A radical cutoff mark means no dizzying fragmentation, but rather a clean break from WP’s past and a running start into what’s fast, bright, and next. This can only happen with some violence — the next wave simply requires more horsepower than anything out now. Support for old phones would cripple the new ones. Your Lumia would only hold back progress. Sorry. No hard feelings.
You can wax cranky over the fact that the phone you bought won’t be swept up in the Win 8 euphoria, but it’s hard to justify the saltiness. By the time WP8 and accompanying handsets are actually available, you’ll probably be approaching upgrade eligibility. If you’re not, it’ll be worth the wait — and you’ll be in good company with the legions of iPhone users screwed out of the latest, far less monumental software releases. This is just nature. And besides, current WP groupies will still get the 7.8 update with most of the best software stuff from 8 — most of all, that smile-inducingly redesigned start screen — that’s more of a compromise than most iPhone owners ever get. Likewise, Windows Phone 8 handsets are getting an 18 month pledge of firmware support. That simply doesn’t exist with Apple or Android.
But all that’s almost beside the point — that point being that Microsoft had to do this. You can pout about being excluded, you can claim you’re being screwed, you can protest over being ripped off, but if you want Windows Phone to continue to not only exist but have a chance to flourish and dominate, you’ll take this as the smart move of a recently genius company trying to save itself and sell you terrific things. So suck it up, and enjoy the good thing you already have.













On monday I decided to try windows phone (switching from my Samsung Galaxy S).
So I got a 1 year contract to test out the Lumia 900. It just came in the post this morning, just after me hearing the news last night.
Is it wrong for me to want to send it back for the HTC one X, even though I hate HTCs ICS look. (cant get S3 cos its only on a 2 year contract). But i love tech and the HTC has a lot of it.
Please someone put my mind at easy and give me a reason to keep this Lumia (and take it out of its box for that matter)!
I’d say send it back. It’s a gorgeous phone, but the updated models coming in October are going to leave it in the dust. Higher spec, better screen, WP8 (which you won’t be getting) and a better camera + camera software. I’d recommend blowing the dust of your previous handset and biting the bullet until the new platform is announced later this year – either that or hold off for an iPhone 5!
Im not an iphone person. So thats of the list.
And i have just set up the contract, so waiting for a win8 phone isnt an option either.
It comes down to having a simple year with this winphone7.8, making my first step into the winphone market (also setting up my windows cloud account which will play a big part in win 8 on my PC later this year).
Or the HTC One X, where I would just basically continue my android life with a lame UI, (i wish it came with stock ICS).
I think i want simplicity as im A.D.D. and constantly am changing and fiddling with my old droid. But im scared in a month im gonna be bored.
Has anyone one got the Lumia 900 / or recommend it?
This is one of the hardest decisions in my tech life, as I worked my mind into thinking i really wanted a winphone.
bro, contracts usually have a 14 day cooling off period in which you can cancel
I have the HTC Titan but I will happily concede that the Lumia 900 is the better phone. It has way better exclusive apps like Nokia Drive (for a few months anyway). The thing is Gorgeous! As for the apps, there is over 100,000 now and there is rarely anything I can’t find anymore. You still aren’t going to get the latest and greatest from iOS straight away but to be honest most of those are just games anyway. Oh an no more Force Closes!
Windows Phone is brilliant but even I would struggle to recommend buying one of the high(er) end phones with WP8 just around the corner..
Even the lower ends don’t really make sense anymore. I know those buying them aren’t necessarily after a smartphone powerhouse but if they hold off a couple of months they’ll be able to get the 710 or Radar for a lot less when the low end WP8 come out.
I’m typing the following as the owner of an iPhone 4S who has been tied to iOS since the iPhone 3G, who works very closely with Microsoft on a day-to-day basis and yet paradoxically has his head turned frequently by the promises of Android.
Forget for a second that Microsoft is one of the biggest companies in the world. Forget that they have a reputation for being bean-counters and for making their beds with businesses rather than the public at large. Consider what you use your devices for and how you would like them to work for you.
I would challenge any ICS handset-toting Android fanboy to put their hand on their heart and tell me that their mobile device represents a clean and uncluttered, logical and thought-out interface. I would challenge them to show me exactly what it is about their beloved OS or its applications that necessitates the kind of horsepower available on the latest top-of-the-line devices and I’d seriously question whether (outside of bragging rights) it truly matters what lies beneath the tips of their fingers and the base of their thumb day-to-day. Surely the most important thing about the device in your hand is the software and hardware elements you interact with, and not what lurks inside. I genuinely believe I could invite a fantasy Martian Man into a room to use an iPhone, a Galaxy S III and a Lumia 900 and he wouldn’t have the foggiest idea which of them had the most powerful engine inside or the sharpest screen etc. Indeed, I believe that he’d notice the slick interface of Windows Phone 7 and the beautiful monolithic design of the Lumia 900 and declare it top of the pile, uncorrupted by the politics that comes from being a fanboy or specification/customisation whore.
Which brings me to my question to iPhone/iPad owners (including myself) Do you upgrade your handset every 18-24months out of loyalty and complacency, or because there is a fundamental, underlying USP that causes you to show such loyalty to a company, suite of devices and an OS which from the outside feel like they’ve been undergoing very little in the way of change since their initial inception less than 5 years ago? Are you experiencing perfection in terms of user-interface, or instead familiarity?
Windows in its Metro iterations is a concept. It is a calculated risk on the part of a company with the intelligence, talent and R&D investment to pull-off a real challenge to the status quo in OS-land that it helped to create. From using Windows Phone 7 and Windows 8 for extended periods, I can picture myself standing over the shoulders of the creators during development as they clearly, defiantly and meticulously questioned the Wheres? and Whys? of Graphical User Interface conventions. There’s an ethos running throughout that questions what the OS can do for the User in terms of its functionality and integration, and NOT what the User can do with the OS. The less a device feels like a computer…and the more it feels like an extension and a tool, the better Microsoft will feel they’ll have done their job.
Microsoft rule the roost. They might have had a slow start in the mobile space, and Windows Phone 7 might have been a false dawn, but their GUIs are installed on more devices around the globe than any other handheld OS combined. Metro is Microsoft playing its card…and whisper it…they have a VERY GOOD hand. Were Microsoft disappointed by the slow uptake of Windows Phone 7? Most likely…however, Windows 8 retains the overarching philosophy and design of Windows Phone 7 because pretty much everybody in the industry and in the media believe that the Metro direction is the right one to take. Microsoft are steadfastly adhering to their principles because they truly believe that they offer the very best user experience available on any platform and that they are uniquely placed to integrate multiple device-types to enhance that experience still further.
My advice? Keep the Lumia 900. Forget the internals, forget that it runs on Windows CE. The device is a triumph of design where it matters in both hardware and software and if there’s one thing I’m sure of, it’s that you won’t spend your days wishing you had ICS, iOS or Windows 8. You device will just work for you in ways that will occasionally bamboozle you the first time you encounter them, but which are far more likely to invoke a smile and a wondering as to why things weren’t always done that way.
I hate to gush…but I really and genuinely believe in Metro. It took a brave company to completely re-engineer the way things are done at OS-level…and it’s quite odd once you realise that the biggest player in the playground is the one taking all the risky moves. Somewhat ironically, Microsoft has dared to “Think Different”, and I’d urge you to also buy into that ideal by sticking with your gut instinct…
Holy long post Batman!
I do get carried away sometimes!
Your posts are always good but wow is this one long! Top read, Flynndean
Easy there flynny. Hope you’re standing on plastic or linoleum. All that gushing, is either true love for something, or a cam site waiting for subscribers.
Dribble Dribble…
I have had WP, Iphone and Android phones, i like to think i am not a biased person and can rationally evaluate devices, unlike some people, for example my mate who i was showing my WP to and explaining the differences between his iphone4, he was saying he was happy with the features on his iphone4, and didnt need any more features at all and could use his iphone4 for rest of his life. He then a week later upgraded to an Iphone 4s, which just goes to show some people for some bizarre reason have an allegiance to a brand. If an iphone would better suite my needs, i would get an iphone, if a new android version came out that was amazing, my wp would end up on ebay.
As flynndean said, you should use the device and see how it works out, most contracts have a 14 or 30 day money back offer so you can cancel if you dont like it and send the device back.
I have said in other posts, i wont get the wp8 update on my phone, but i will get the 7.8 and potentially a 7.9, i will get features that havent been announced yet (like more social integration etc, anyone who says otherwise i will make you a bet if you would like), i will also get the new size live tiles and the new wallet feature. I could happily use them until my next upgrade in 12 months or w/e
Thanks daniejam and flynndean.
Im gonna stick to the lumia and see how it works for me.
I have tried Android and now its on to WinPhone.
I almost forgot how I convinced myself into getting the lumia by actually looking at what I did with it and not what it can/cant do.
I used my old phone alot, but most of the time was spent on a few selected tasks. Gchat, email, youtube, browsing, rottentomattoing and a bit of light gaming.
Which i can do on this phone with a simple and elegant UI.
My mind is at rest and I’m gonna open up my phone, annoyingly have to charge it for several hours, then test it out.
if you use youtube a lot, deffo get at looking youtube pro, can just set videos to download in the background while you do other stuff etc and just watch them once downloaded (i know its available for iphones etc, but my mates with iphones / android didnt know about it)
Blimey Dean, that’s a long old post, but can’t disagree with most of it. Regarding ‘I would challenge any ICS handset-toting Android fanboy to put their hand on their heart and tell me that their mobile device represents a clean and uncluttered, logical and thought-out interface’ you are going to have to define your terms, my phone is set up just the way I want it. the apps that account for over 95% of my usage are available to me almost instantly as are important toggles such as bluetooth and wifi. My auto changing APOD wallpaper means it always looks beautiful too.
will have to check out APOD, had another app for that function but it slowed the phone down.
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.blork.anpod is what I’m using.
ooooh i thought you meant a general wallpaper switcher, ill try this one out, cheers Darrell
I can’t help but feel that Android handset manufacturers are in something of an arms-race with no real synergy between platform and device. It feels like Intel in the Pentium 4 days where they were chasing the MHz with little regard for what the numbers actually meant. Microsoft leaving Windows CE behind will only exacerbate the gap.
I don’t know how you are with your cars, but for me, ICS is the technological equivalent of an American Muscle Car (say a Ford GT or a Corvette). On paper it looks like the package has everything you could possibly want…and if you wanted to, there’s enough of a modding community that you could tinker with your options or in a workshop for relatively little expense and completely customise your ride for your needs.
But then you have Microsoft, who have delivered something more refined. They have developed a German Saloon of an OS which I’d compare to something like a BMW 3-Series (maybe the mid-range 320d).
In a straight-line race between the two, on paper…the Muscle Car should win…but in terms of performance, you’re certainly going to get more bang for your buck with Microsoft/BMW (indeed a very similar BHP from the German car despite a comparatively under-powered engine). Also, with Microsoft (and the BMW) you just feel like the experience has been designed from the ground up with you (the user/driver) in mind.
Increasingly, I’m coming to realise which of the two I’d prefer to live with day-to-day…
I hope that makes some kind of sense. I’m not knocking Google’s approach; I just feel like there are three very different approaches to the idea of a touchscreen OS and that Android potentially has a fight on its hands in a way that nobody really would have envisaged maybe a year ago. Microsoft appears to be digging its trenches for the long-game with Surface, Windows 8 etc. and only a fool would bet against them making some serious waves.
Any suggestions as to what iOS represents in the car world would be much appreciated!
I think Joe Belfoire’s comments about the platform being tested on 64 core hardware relate to the desktop/laptop versions rather than the mobile platforms. At least that was my take from the presentation.
* Joe Belfiore – apologies!
Most people don’t give a damn about “the future of the ecosystem”. They give a damn about the future of their phones. This is a move that will given nothing but bad publicity – think how much stick Android OEMs get for not supporting the latest flavour on a phone that’s a year old…
After watching the announcement late last night, I couldn’t agree with your statement above more.
I hope they announce the WP8 early, my contract with o2 finishes on the 6th September.
The only question is if they think they need to screw over the entire worlds use of earlier versions of windows than Windows 8. After all it makes sense to ditch all those users of free software written for windows and force everybody into a walled Metro garden too.
“much-needed fresh start.”
So that makes two ‘fresh-starts’ in just a few years, as they pretty much did that in the big win mob 6.x to 7 changeover.
If they keep doing that it’d seriously put me off buying into the platform
anyone know what the subject of the painting used in this article is, i recognise it but dont know what its called
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judith_Beheading_Holofernes_(Caravaggio)
cheers dude….must have been a bloody sharp sword cos “all her might” doesnt seem like it would amount to much!
iOS 6 is coming to the iPhone 3GS that’s far older than 18 months. Right?
- “Windows Phone 8 handsets are getting an 18 month pledge of firmware support. That simply doesn’t exist with Apple or Android.”