There have been plenty of civil cases against architects over the years, for all manner of negligence. But, today, an extremely rare criminal case was decided: An architect was sentenced to a year in prison after pleading no contest to the manslaughter of a Los Angeles firefighter who died while trying to contain a fire in a home the architect had designed for himself and his girlfriend.
The case dates back to 2011, when a fire broke out in the Hollywood Hills home of a German architect named Gerhard Becker, who designed the building himself. The fire began in one of four fireplaces that had been manufactured for outdoor use but hidden within the houses itself; this means they were in clear violation of local building regulations.
The flames then melted a water pipe, which leaked thousands of gallons of water into a drop ceiling above the heads of the firefighters battling the fire. When the ceiling collapsed, it crushed 61 year old Glenn Allen, who died the next day of his injuries. The New York Times reports that the home was used to film an episode of America's Next Top Model only two days later.
Becker allegedly had the fireplaces installed after the mansion had cleared its inspection, writing, "I want this to be installed after the final inspection so we don't have any final delays by the inspector."
In an in depth play by play of the court case from March, LA Weekly describes Becker's less than remorseful behaviour after the fire, which probably didn't do much to endear him to the public:
Becker was interviewed by fire investigators, but two months after they last spoke to him, he broke the lease on his home, sold two vehicles and flew to Switzerland and then Spain, where he began to build another luxury home. There he set up construction companies in the name of his wife, a yoga instructor, investigators said.
It's extremely rare for an architect to be convicted in a criminal case of negligence, although it was much more common in earlier centuries, before the advent of legit construction standards and building codes—which meant that collapses, too, were common. These days, it's far more likely for a client to sue for civil damages resulting shoddy construction or a delayed project. For example, Santiago Calatrava is currently being sued for damages by his hometown of Valencia, whose eight year old opera house is already crumbling.
One high profile instance that could've, theoretically, turned into a criminal case involved a shooting at a Frank Gehry designed building at Case Western in 2003. At the time, some suggested that the complexity of the building's layout played a roll in preventing victims from easily escaping. That accusation, however, like most others, involved too many other factors to place the blame solely on design. But, in the case of Becker, who intentionally misled building inspectors and endangered 80 firefighters, killing one, the blame is clear.