How Crazy is Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars?

By Maddie Stone on at

Yesterday, billionaire tech entrepreneur Elon Musk unveiled his hotly anticipated plan to send humans to live — and die — on Mars. And not just a few humans: a lot of them.

In a talk that wavered between overreaching science, fair presentation and straight-up science fiction Musk described sending fleets of spacecraft, each packed hundreds of colonists, to live on a dusty and airless wasteland that we’re apparently going to fix up with nuclear reactors and artificial magnetic fields.

Read more: How Elon Musk Plans to Go to Mars

It’s easy to dismiss most of what Musk outlined as little more than a pipe dream of some rich bloke. We saw a lot of beautiful rocket renderings, along with some staggeringly generous estimates regarding the cost of a ticket to Mars (“close to the median house price in the US”, which currently stands at $284k, or about £220k – pocket change, then). But when it came to hard deadlines, or concrete steps toward achieving our interplanetary immigration, Musk’s opus was thin. Most importantly, we have no idea who is going to pay for all of this.

“Anyone who has enough money can send something to Mars.”

Here’s what we do know: SpaceX’s short-term goal, of sending robotic landers to Mars within the next few years, is definitely doable. We also know that the Interplanetary Transport System Musk outlined yesterday will not materialise without an enormous amount of financial and technical support from the international community.

“I think it’s perfectly feasible that [SpaceX] will land a Dragon capsule on Mars either in 2018 or 2020,” Bobby Braun, an associate professor of space technology at the Georgia Institute of Technology told Gizmodo.

As SpaceX first announced in April, it intends to start flying uncrewed “Red Dragon” missions to Mars, beginning in late 2018. These missions will consist of a Falcon Heavy rocket — a souped-up version of the Falcon 9, which SpaceX plans to debut next year — and a Dragon-2 robotic capsule, whose technology builds off the human-rated Dragon capsule SpaceX is developing under NASA’s Commercial Crew Program.

“The plan is to send a Dragon-2 to Mars in a few years, and then another in 2020,” Musk said during his talk yesterday. “We want to establish a steady cadence, with every Mars rendezvous,” he added, referring to the launch window that occurs every 26 months, when the distance between Earth and Mars is at its minimum.

How Crazy Is Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars?Artist’s rendering of a Dragon-2 capsule on Mars (Image: SpaceX)

A critical goal of the Red Dragon missions will be to test and refine propulsive landing technology for entering Mars’s atmosphere, descending, and touching down softly. All robotic missions to the surface of Mars so far have relied on parachutes to slow their descent through the atmosphere, but the Dragon-2 is going to be the heaviest human-made object to touch the Red Planet by a wide margin; that means it’ll need beefier brakes. No doubt, SpaceX intends for the this propulsive braking technology to feed forward into more ambitious crewed missions to Mars, which, based on some of the details we heard yesterday, will feature spacecraft that are utterly enormous by modern standards.

It isn’t clear how many uncrewed Red Dragon missions SpaceX hopes to fly to Mars, nor is it clear how much these interplanetary test-runs will cost. In July, NASA administrator Jim Reuter told Space Policy News that he estimates SpaceX will be spending some $300 million on the programme; that's the equivalent of £230 million.

NASA will also be making a contribution to the Red Dragon missions, mainly in the form of engineering consultancy, which Reuter has valued at roughly £24 million worth of time over four years. In exchange for advice and communications support during SpaceX’s robotic missions to Mars, the space agency will be privy to precious flight data collected during Dragon-2's entry, descent, and landing — data that it will likely need to inform its own strategy for getting boots on the Red Planet’s surface in the 2030s.

At this point, nothing about the timetable or cost of the Red Dragon missions seem prohibitive; assuming SpaceX soon gets back on its feet from the latest explosion disaster, it might even make the 2018 launch window. “It’s certainly technically feasible — anyone who has enough money can send something to Mars,” said a senior executive in the aerospace industry, who preferred not to be quoted by name .

How Crazy Is Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars?An artist’s rendering of the Interplanetary Transport System (Image: SpaceX)

But making the jump from small, robotic landers to an “Interplanetary Transport System” capable of sending thousands of human settlers to the Red Planet is not going to be easy or cheap. That latter system, which pairs an utterly enormous “zero gravity game” rocket with an equally grandiose spaceship capable of carrying “100 passengers at least”, was the focus of Musk’s talk yesterday. As he freely acknowledged, it might not happen.

“Obviously it’s going to be a challenge to fund this whole endeavour,” Musk said. “Right now we’re trying to make as much progress with the resources we have, and keep moving forward.”

If we had any doubts that SpaceX, and really, Musk’s entire career, has been a lead-up to this vision, those were laid to rest yesterday. Not only is the billionaire counting on his rocket company’s future earnings— “launching satellites and servicing the space station” — to fund humanity’s cosmic diaspora, the electric car salesman himself apparently doesn’t have “any other motivation for personally accumulating assets”.

How Crazy Is Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars?System architecture for the Interplanetary Transport System. Image: SpaceX

But even if Musk throws his entire net worth into building the largest rocket ever — a 12-metre-diameter booster, 17-metre-diameter spaceship, and 122-metre-tall stack — it’s hard to imagine that it will be enough for more than a single prototype. He needs help, either from venture capitalists or government space agencies. NASA would be an obvious partner, but so far, the space agency has not given any indication that it’s going to support Musk’s martian colonial ambitions in any manner other than kind thoughts, prayers, laughter, and tears.

“NASA applauds all those who want to take the next giant leap — and advance the journey to Mars,” a NASA spokesperson told Gizmodo in an email. “We are very pleased that the global community is working to meet the challenges of a sustainable human presence on Mars.”

As for the Big Fucking Rocket? “This is a SpaceX-led initiative in the conceptual design phase,” the spokesperson said. “As it develops, NASA may identify elements in which we would have an interest.”

In other words, NASA is keeping its options open but maintaining a healthy scepticism, for now. And you can hardly blame the space agency. NASA has, after all, already taken a huge gamble on SpaceX with the Commercial Crew Program, which is now at least a year behind its schedule to send American astronauts to the Space Station.

“On a hundred-year timeframe, my grandmother has seen changes just as remarkable as what Elon talked about.”

Even if SpaceX can’t woo NASA, there might be another space agency willing to take a gamble on the billionaire’s vision. The list of space-capable nations is growing fast, and newer players, like Luxembourg, have already indicated their interest in supporting high-risk, high-reward commercial ventures. And, there’s always the possibility that another ambitious billionaire — say, that Russian guy who wants to send robotic spacecraft to Alpha Centauri — will throw some seed money in.

Optimistically, Musk says we could be sending the first humans to Mars in a decade. In reality, SpaceX has not yet sent a single human into orbit or a single robotic spacecraft to Mars. Its rockets are still blowing up occasionally for reasons unknown, and its CEO is notoriously bad at meeting deadlines.

How Crazy Is Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars?Image: SpaceX

It’ll be highly exciting to watch SpaceX take its first baby steps toward Mars. But in between the Commercial Crew Program, the Red Dragon missions, and the “kind of like Battlestar Galactica” vision for humanity’s future are a lot of incremental steps and intermediate milestones Musk glossed over: designing, building and testing larger and more advanced rockets; and inventing the technologies needed to extract resources from Mars and sustain human life on it. Assuming SpaceX has good fortune and secures ample investment, those steps will could still take decades.

Musk is not an idiot: he knows it’ll take a a lot of work to accomplish what he outlined yesterday. The point of his speech was not to show us that SpaceX alone can get it all done, but to convince the world that what SpaceX was founded to do is worth it.

And, who knows? Maybe planting that seed right now really is the first step toward a million-strong colony on Mars in 2100s. “I have a grandmother who’s 103,” Braun said. “She was around when airplanes were beginning to fly, and cars were being introduced. She’s seen humans land on the moon and cure countless diseases. On a hundred-year timeframe, my grandmother has seen changes just as remarkable as what Elon talked about.”