Manslaughter Conviction for Italian Scientists Overturned

By Sarah Zhang on at

In 2012, the Italian courts handed down a decision that you could say sent shockwaves across the world. Seven Italian scientists were sentenced to six years in prison. Their crime? Failing to warn the public about earthquake risks right before a magnitude 6.3 quake killed 309 people. Six of those convictions have now been overturned.

The seven scientists were all members of a government commission that met to discuss the risk of earthquakes near L'Aquila, Italy back in 2009. They tried to reassure residents, who were on edge because of frequent tremors in the area, but the reassurances only backfired when the big one hit a few days later.

An appeals court acquitted six of the seven scientists of the manslaughter charges; they're now free to free unless the convictions are reinstated by a higher court. The seventh, Bernardo De Bernardinis, former deputy head of Italy's Civil Protection Department, was sentenced to two years in prison, also pending an appeal. De Bernardinis was singled out because of comments he made to the press about how frequent tremors dissipated energy, a discredited idea among seismologists.

The whole earthquake manslaughter trial seems outrageous from afar, but without giving the Italian court system too much credit, I'd urge you to read David Wolman's piece on how and why the scientists got convicted in the first place.

It doesn't make the convictions any more justified (thank god the appeals court came to its senses) but it captures the anger and the anguish of the human tragedy behind it. [ScienceInsider]

Top image: AP Photo/Sandro Perozzi