X-Ray of Degas Painting Reveals a Mysterious Secret Portrait

By Ria Misra on at

For almost a hundred years, viewers have speculated over a shadowy figure that appears to be slowly emerging from behind a famous Degas portrait. Now, researchers have used a new imaging technique to look behind the painting—and they’ve discovered a secret portrait.

The artwork in question is Edgar Degas’s Portrait of a Woman, painted around 1876. At first, it appeared to be — as the name suggests — a fairly ordinary portrait of a 19th-century woman. But around 1922, viewers began to suspect there was something unusual about the portrait. As the painting aged, an outline of a second figure started to become clearer and clearer.

X-Ray of Degas Painting Reveals a Mysterious Secret Portrait

The hidden portrait overlaid over the existing portrait (Image: Scientific Reports)

The conservators of the painting at the National Gallery of Victoria in Melbourne, Australia, were curious but didn’t want to damage the existing portrait. And so, using a new X-ray technique, researchers discovered that underneath the portrait is a never-before-seen portrait of a woman that they believe to be frequent Degas model, Emma Dobigny. Traditional X-ray techniques wouldn’t have been sufficient to reveal the image. Instead, a newly developed X-ray detector that uses fluorescence, called the Maia detector, is responsible for the depth of the scan. The process is detailed in a new paper in Scientific Reports.

“A traditional X-ray of a painting relies on heavy elements such as lead to absorb the X-rays and provide image contrast and provides minimal quantitative or specific elemental identification information,” co-author of the paper, Daryl Howard of Australian Synchrotron, told Gizmodo. “[The Maia detector] allows us to scan large areas of an object such as a painting in a short amount of time in a non-invasive manner.”

X-Ray of Degas Painting Reveals a Mysterious Secret Portrait

Different scans of the hidden portrait that researchers used to uncover the brushwork sequence (Image: Scientific Reports)

The new X-ray images were detailed enough that they didn’t just reveal the portrait underneath, they also revealed what the portrait had looked like at multiple stages. For instance, the researchers were able to see that at one point, Degas had painted a pair of large, pointed, elf ears on the woman in the hidden portrait, before eventually painting over them for a set more like Dobigny’s own.

Although we now know what lies beneath the portrait, we still don’t know why it’s there. Sometimes hidden painting are simply due to an artist’s commitment to not wasting their materials. But sometimes what an artist hides underneath a painting has meaning for the painting above it as well. For instance, this 17th-century seascape includes a secret portrait of a beached whale. However, the reason behind Degas’s hidden portrait remains a secret, and art historians can’t exactly ask Degas why it’s there. [Scientific Reports]