You may have thought, “Hey, if we’re threatened by an incoming asteroid, we should just nuke it!” You’re not alone: a team of Russian scientists are working on a plot to do so, by detonating miniature asteroids in a lab.
In fact, several groups of researchers are now toying with the idea of asteroid nuking for the sake of planetary defence. The Russian team has even calculated about how much firepower they’d need to perform such a feat.
According to the translated paper published in the Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics: “Given the scale factor and the results of laboratory experiments, the undeniable destruction of a chondritic asteroid 200 m in diameter by a nuclear explosion with an energy above 3 Mt was shown to be possible.”
That’s three megatonnes to blow up an asteroid twice the size of a football pitch, or a bomb 200 times more powerful than the bomb dropped on Hiroshima.
This paper should be taken with a grain of salt, of course. The researchers from the Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology, Russian Federal Nuclear Centre and ROSATOM didn’t nuke a real 200-metre asteroid in a zero gravity environment. Instead, they used a laser pulse to zap a four-millimetre asteroid model, based on the composition of meteorite fragments. That laser pulse was certainly high energy for its size, 200 joules (the energy required to slide a two-ish pound box 600 feet on a frictionless surface). But that’s no nuke.
A very silly image that came with this press release. Illustration: Elena Khavina (MPIT)
The Russians aren’t the only ones considering nuking asteroids. Universe Today reports that NASA is working on a project called HAMMER, or Hyper-velocity Asteroid Mitigation Mission for Emergency Response. As writer Evan Gough notes, it’s just an idea. An idea to nuke asteroids.
These ideas aren’t totally out there, though. NASA does track most of the so-called “potentially hazardous” near-Earth objects, none of which are actually hazardous today. Given a 100-year warning, there are a lot of simple things you can do to slightly perturb an asteroid’s orbit to prevent it from hitting us. But as we’ve noted in the past, NASA does not track all of the nearby asteroids smaller than 140 metres in diameter.
A 140-metre untracked meteorite showing up out of nowhere would spell bad news. Even a 20-metre object, the size of the Chelyabinsk meteorite, hitting an urban area could cause catastrophe.
“They have thought about the logistics of the problem from the practical side, including how much advance warning you would need to send up a rocket in time, and how small the fragments of the asteroid would need to be, in order to burn up in the Earth’s atmosphere,” Karen Daniels, professor at North Carolina State University, told Gizmodo. “This one study goes a long way towards specifying the circumstances under which deploying a nuclear charge at the surface of an asteroid might be sufficient to address crises, as well as pitfalls that would cause it to fail.”
Still, there’s way more work to be done. Asteroids can vary wildly in their composition. Some are large chunks of rock, while other are “rubble piles” loosely held together by a tiny gravitational force, according to the European Space Agency.
The researchers plan to further study the effect of their lasers on other model asteroids.
So, don’t go asking for space nuke proliferation just yet. Or at least, don’t go basing your judgment simply on what happens to pebbles in a lab. [Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics]