In 2013, marine scientists witnessed a real-life, aquatic version of Contagion. Over the summer, divers in Monterrey, California were treated to a horror scene of sea stars – or starfish – with limbs torn asunder and bodies disintegrating. Soon, major aquariums up and down the U.S. West Coast reported their starfish went from paragons of health to dead in weeks. Beaches became littered with dead and dying starfish or their remnants.
Scientists knew little about the disease causing them to waste away. While its origins remain a mystery, new findings show it was turbocharged by the freakishly warm blob of water that engulfed the U.S. West Coast from 2013 to 2015. The research, released Wednesday in Science Advances, also reveals just how dramatically it reshaped the starfish communities along the coast, including completely wiping out sunflower stars from large parts of their range. The impacts show how infectious diseases and climate change can interact in terrible ways, and that in the oceans, those impacts could catch us off-guard.
“The sea star wasting disease is one of the most extensive marine epidemics for wildlife,” Drew Harvell, an infectious disease ecologist at Cornell University, told Gizmodo. “It’s an impressive example of a multi-host disease that basically reshaped our underwater ecosystem.”
Harvell and her fellow researchers used nearly 20,000 observations collected from dives and trawling from 2004 to 2017 to get a handle on starfish populations from California to Alaska, including British Columbia. The data chronicles starfish abundance from before and after the disease hit. They also pulled satellite ocean temperature data to look at its relationship with the starfish die-off.
The findings show that once the disease showed up in 2013, starfish populations fell off a cliff. And when the Pacific got super warm thanks to the blob in 2014, the die-off got even more extreme.
“It was shockingly fast in its progression and unprecedented in the number of species that were hit,” Harvell said.
Underwater photograph showing initial outbreak at Sackinaw Rock, BC, Canada. The two photos were taken 20 days apart at the same location in October 2012. Photo: Neil McDonald
In total, 20 types of starfish were impacted by the disease, but the study focuses on the sunflower sea star. In the 2000s, they were reliably found up and down the coast in colonies of dozens or even hundreds. But since 2014, they’ve been practically eradicated. The findings show 100 percent drop in biomass in large swaths of coastal California and Oregon, 99.2 percent in Washington, and 96 percent in British Columbia. All that is a fancy of way saying they’ve basically been completely wiped out.
“There’s a lot of seascape here from Mexico to Alaska, and to say its imperiled all the way to Alaska is a pretty shocking thing,” Harvell said.
While the disease would likely have wrought havoc regardless, it’s clear that the hot waters that cooked the coast sped up the stars’ demise. The Pacific Ocean reached up to 7.2 degrees Fahrenheit (4 degrees Celsius) above normal at the height of the blob, which not only affected the stars but a whole host of other species from algae to crabs.
“For the correlation with elevated water temperature, I think the data are as sound as they can be, given the limitations of the data sets,” Melissa Miner, a researcher at the University of California, Santa Cruz who has also studied the star die-off, told Gizmodo. She praised the study as a whole but pointed to the need for direct water observations to really be able to hone in exactly how starfish wasting disease and hot water interacted.
Some research suggests climate change played a role in creating the blob, and it damn well is causing the oceans to heat up as a whole. That raises the risk of catastrophic impacts on ecosystems, especially for diseases and invasive species that thrive in warm water.
The sunflower star is a keystone species, eating up urchins and keeping the ecosystem in balance. Its absence has allowed urchins to proliferate and chow down on kelp, which in turn means fish, crabs, and other species lose their habitat and perish or migrate. It’s what ecologists call a trophic cascade, and it’s having direct impacts on humans back onshore, particularly fishing operations that rely on a functioning ecosystem and fish to, well, exist.
Harvell said that with the sunflower sea star largely gone along the West Coast, the main hope for its recovery is that populations in Alaska are still trucking along. One possible path forward is breeding them in captivity to ensure a viable population exists while researchers try to unravel the cause of the starfish wasting disease. Other stars are showing some signs of recovery and could also help researchers understand what happened and prepare for when the next oceanic calamity inevitably hits.
Featured image: Edward Gullekson